Jared BakerWest Hills Honda Text Jared

Home / Compare / Pilot vs. the competition / vs. Highlander

Honda Pilot vs. Toyota Highlander

Updated October 2026

Base trims side by side, where each one wins, and my honest take as a Honda guy who will tell you when the other car fits better.

Where the Pilot wins

  • Lower starting price ($42,395 vs. $46,270)
  • More horsepower (285 vs. 265)
  • More room behind the 3rd row (19 vs. 16 cu ft)
  • More max cargo space (87 vs. 84 cu ft)
  • Stowable 2nd-row middle seat (per Honda)
  • More passenger room (158.4 vs. 136.3–141.8 cu ft, per Honda)

Where the Highlander wins

  • Better EPA combined mpg at the base trim (24 vs. 22)
  • Higher base towing (5,000 vs. 3,500 lb)
  • AWD standard on every trim

Side by side

Base trims compared. Starting MSRP before destination.

SpecHonda PilotToyota Highlander
Model year · base trim2026 · Sport FWD2026 · XLE AWD
Starting MSRP$42,395$46,270
Engine3.5L V6, 10-speed auto2.4L turbo 4-cyl
Horsepower285 hp265 hp
DrivetrainFWD; AWD from $44,495AWD standard
EPA combined mpg2224
Seats87 or 8
Cargo behind 3rd row19 cu ft16 cu ft
Cargo behind 2nd row49 cu ft48 cu ft
Max cargo87 cu ft84 cu ft
Towing3,500 lb (base trim)5,000 lb
Worth knowingTrailSport from $50,595Larger Grand Highlander sold separately

Feature check

Per Honda's comparison of the 2026 Pilot with the 2025 Toyota Highlander. These are Honda's figures, so the trims differ from the base-trim table above.

SpecHonda PilotToyota Highlander
Automatic transmission10-speed8-speed
Stowable 2nd-row center seatStandardNot available
Google built-inStandardNot available
Drive modes54
Passenger volume158.4 cu ft136.3–141.8 cu ft

Base-trim specs and starting MSRP (before destination) from Cars.com research pages: 2026 Pilot · 2026 Highlander · Honda: Pilot vs. the competition. Checked October 2026. Prices and specs change during the year, so confirm the exact vehicle before you buy.

My honest take

The Highlander gets better mpg, comes with AWD and tows more at its base trim, but it starts about $3,900 higher.

The Pilot has a V6, more room behind the third row and more space overall, and Honda's comparison shows a lot more passenger room. If the third row actually gets used, bring someone to sit back there.

From the showroom

If you're shopping three rows, the third row is the whole point, so test it like you'll use it. Climb back there yourself, then put the kids or the in-laws back there for a lap around the lot. Compare AWD to AWD on price too: the Pilot with AWD still starts below the Highlander.

More on the Pilot →

Cross-shopping? I'll help.

I'd rather you buy the right car than the one I sell. Text me and let's compare.

Text Jared